Jurnal Ekonomi dan Studi Pembangunan
Abstract
This netnographic study explores the paradox of adolescent digital consumption on Instagram, driven by intense passions and the Fear of Missing Out (FOMO). We investigate whether this continuous engagement, often akin to addiction, eventually leads to subjective psychological satiation, explicitly serving as a qualitative reflection rather than a cardinal economic measurement of the Law of Diminishing Marginal Utility. Focusing on Andrehendarto's Instagram account, we qualitatively analyze user interactions, posts, and semi-structured interviews. We examine a dataset of 150 posts, over 1,200 comments observed during a 3 month observation period (December 2023-February 2024), with comments systematically categorized and filtered through thematic sorting to ensure data saturation and thematic reliability, and in depth interviews with 12 active adolescent followers. To address ethical standards for underage participants, parental/guardian informed consent was rigorously obtained alongside individual assent for participants aged 16–17 years old. A crucial finding highlights that while initial engagement provides high satisfaction, this wanes over time due to budgetary constraints, limiting their ability to continue acquiring new items or experiences that Instagram promotes. This study proposes a new theoretical framework aspirational dissonance, explicitly distinguished from traditional social comparison and general frustration theories by focusing on the friction between digitally stimulated commercial desires and rigid youth budget constraints and offers three theoretical propositions that bridge economic constraints with psychological fatigue. This study offers critical insights for platforms and brands to foster healthier digital environments by acknowledging the limits of engagement and the financial realities of young users.
First Page
118
Last Page
134
Recommended Citation
Kristina, A.,
&
Tsaniyah, A. E.
(2026).
The Instagram Economy: When Teen Passions and the Fear of Missing Out Hit Diminishing Returns.
Jurnal Ekonomi dan Studi Pembangunan, 18(2), 118-134.
DOI: 10.17988/2502-7115.1109
Available at:
https://citeus.um.ac.id/jesp/vol18/iss2/8
