•  
  •  
 

Publication Ethics Statement

General Principles

Proceedings Series of Educational Studies is committed to honest, fair, and transparent publishing. Everyone involved must take responsibility for their part in the publication process. This includes authors, reviewers, editors, conference organizers, and the publisher.

The series uses guidance from the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) to help address publication ethics concerns. These principles apply from submission and peer review through publication and any later corrections or investigations.

{ top }

Responsibilities of Authors

Originality and Proper Attribution

Authors must submit original work and give credit to the sources they use. This includes published text, data, research tools, images, and ideas. Exact wording taken from another source must be clearly marked as a quotation and cited. Authors must obtain permission to use copyrighted material when required.

Authors must not copy others’ work without credit, reuse substantial parts of their own published text without disclosure, invent data, change evidence dishonestly, or present findings in a misleading way. A similarity score can help editors check a paper, but the score alone cannot prove or rule out plagiarism.

{ top }

Duplicate and Overlapping Publication

Authors must not submit the same paper to another publication while it is being considered by this series. A submission must not largely repeat an existing publication without a clear explanation and an acceptable reason.

Authors must tell the editor about related manuscripts, earlier conference papers, abstracts, preprints, and other public versions. An earlier presentation or abstract does not automatically prevent publication, but any overlap must be explained.

If a full paper has already been published, the editor must assess whether the new submission meets the requirements for originality, proper credit, and permission to reuse material.

{ top }

Authorship and Contributions

Authors must have made a substantial intellectual contribution to the work. They must also help write or critically revise the paper, approve the final version, and take responsibility for their contributions. All authors must help resolve questions about the accuracy and honesty of the work.

People must not be listed as authors simply because of their position, reputation, payment, or personal relationship. People who qualify as authors must not be left out. Other contributors should be acknowledged with their permission.

The corresponding author must check that the author list is complete, the author details are correct, and everyone agrees to submission. Any request to change authorship must explain the reason and include written agreement from everyone affected. Changes require editorial approval.

{ top }

Accuracy, Data, and Reproducibility

Authors must describe their methods, findings, and limitations accurately. They must provide enough information for readers to assess the study and, where appropriate, repeat it.

Authors should keep relevant research records and provide supporting data or documents when reasonably requested. Any sharing must respect consent, privacy, ownership rights, and other valid restrictions. The paper should explain any limits on access to the data.

Images and other research materials must not be changed in ways that give a false impression of the evidence.

{ top }

Research involving people, identifiable personal information, animals, or other activities requiring ethical review must follow the relevant institutional rules and regulations.

Where required, authors must name the ethics committee that approved the study and provide the approval reference. If approval was waived or not required, they must explain why.

Authors must obtain informed consent when required. They must also obtain appropriate permission to publish information or images that identify a person. Participants’ privacy must be protected, with particular care for people who may be vulnerable.

{ top }

Competing Interests and Funding

Authors must report financial, professional, personal, or institutional interests that could influence the research or how its findings are explained.

They must also name relevant funding sources and describe the funder’s role. If there are no competing interests, the paper should state this.

{ top }

Use of Artificial Intelligence

Artificial intelligence tools cannot be listed as authors because they cannot take responsibility for published work.

Authors must report substantial use of generative AI to prepare text, images, code, analyses, or other parts of the paper. They must name the tool and explain how it was used. If AI is part of the research methods, its role must be described clearly enough for readers to assess it.

Authors remain responsible for everything they submit, including accuracy, originality, references, permissions, and confidentiality. AI must not be used to invent evidence or references or hide research misconduct.

{ top }

Errors Identified After Publication

Authors who find a significant error in their published paper must promptly contact the editorial office and help correct the record.

{ top }

Responsibilities of Editors and Volume Editors

Fair and Independent Decisions

Editors must judge papers on their academic quality, methods, originality, clarity, ethical standards, and relevance to the proceedings.

Decisions must not be influenced by sponsorship, registration fees, publication charges, personal relationships, or pressure from institutions. Attending a conference or being accepted to present does not automatically guarantee publication.

{ top }

Management of Peer Review

Editors must arrange suitable expert review and clearly explain how it works. Each conference or volume must state its review model, reviewer requirements, and decision process. Content that has not received external peer review must be clearly identified.

Editors must take steps to prevent fake reviews, false reviewer identities, coordinated attempts to manipulate reviews, and improper influence over reviewer selection.

{ top }

Confidentiality and Competing Interests

Editors must keep confidential submissions and review materials private. They must not use unpublished information for personal benefit.

Editors must disclose interests that could affect their judgment and leave the handling of affected papers to another editor. Papers written by editors, organizers, or editorial board members must be handled independently and follow the applicable review process.

{ top }

Ethical Oversight

Editors must assess credible ethical concerns raised before or after publication. They must seek explanations and work with the publisher and relevant institutions when needed.

{ top }

Responsibilities of Reviewers

Reviewers must accept a paper only if they have the right expertise and can complete the review on time. They must disclose competing interests and decline the review if those interests prevent a fair assessment.

Reviews must be fair, helpful, respectful, and supported by clear reasons. Reviewers should point out weaknesses in methods, unsupported conclusions, missing credit to sources, and possible ethical problems.

Papers and review correspondence must remain confidential. Reviewers must not use unpublished information for personal benefit or contact authors directly without the editor’s permission.

Reviewers must not upload confidential papers or review materials to external AI services unless the editor explicitly allows it and suitable confidentiality protections are in place. Reviewers remain responsible for their assessments.

Suggested citations must have a clear academic purpose. Reviewers must not request references mainly to increase citation counts.

{ top }

Responsibilities of Conference Organizers and the Publisher

Conference organizers must provide accurate information about the event, editors, review process, publication requirements, fees, and publication schedule.

Claims about indexing, publishing partnerships, and where papers can be found must be verifiable. Organizers must not promise acceptance or indexing in return for payment.

The publisher oversees ethical standards across the series, helps editors address concerns, and provides ways to publish corrections and other notices. Business interests must not override fair editorial decisions.

Copyright, licensing, access conditions, and fees must be explained clearly before authors agree to publication.

{ top }

Allegations of Misconduct

Anyone may report a concern using the editorial or publisher contact details on the series website. Reports should identify the paper, explain the concern, and include supporting evidence where available. Anonymous reports will be assessed if they provide enough information.

The editorial office and publisher will assess concerns fairly, keep relevant records, and give those involved a reasonable opportunity to respond. Information will be kept confidential as far as possible.

When needed, a concern may be referred to an author’s institution, funder, or another appropriate organization. Editors assess whether the published work can be trusted. A formal investigation of research conduct may need to be carried out by the institution.

Depending on the evidence, action may include asking for an explanation or revision, rejecting a paper, publishing a correction or expression of concern, or retracting the paper. Any further restrictions must be proportionate to the issue and explained to those affected.

{ top }

Corrections, Expressions of Concern, and Retractions

A correction will be published when an error needs to be fixed but the main findings remain valid.

An expression of concern may be published to alert readers when serious questions remain unresolved or an investigation is still in progress.

A paper may be retracted when its findings cannot be trusted, substantial plagiarism or duplicate publication is confirmed, the research was unethical, or serious manipulation has undermined the publication process.

Each notice will explain the reason for the action and link to the paper. Retracted papers will normally remain available and be clearly marked as retracted to preserve the publication record. Removal will be considered only in exceptional cases with strong legal, privacy, or safety reasons.

{ top }

Complaints and Appeals

Authors may appeal an editorial decision by explaining their reasons and providing supporting evidence through the published editorial contact.

Complaints about editorial conduct or publication procedures may be sent to the publisher. Anyone with a competing interest in the matter must not decide its outcome. An independent assessment will be arranged when appropriate, and the decision will be explained.

{ top }

Post-Publication Discussion

The series welcomes comments and academic discussion about published papers when they are supported by evidence. Significant concerns will be assessed and may lead to an author response, a correction, or another editorial action.

Comments must stay relevant and respectful and must not include personal attacks.

{ top }